Milk Chocolate Stuffed Jack-O’-Lantern Cookies

When the leaves turn golden and the air carries that crisp, cozy chill, my oven is always busy. Fall is my favorite season for baking, and these Milk Chocolate Stuffed Jack-O’-Lantern Cookies are my new go-to treat. They’re buttery, warmly spiced, and filled with creamy milk chocolate, all wrapped up in a festive pumpkin-shaped cookie.

Think of them as the sweet spot where classic sugar cookies meet sandwich cookies—only with a gooey chocolate center that makes everyone smile. They’re fun enough for Halloween, nostalgic enough for Thanksgiving gatherings, and comforting enough to enjoy with a mug of tea on a chilly evening.

I tested this recipe seven times before sharing it with you. That means I baked, adjusted, and sampled my way through plenty of pumpkin-shaped cookies (tough job, I know!) to make sure they’re foolproof. The results? A cookie that’s soft without being cakey, holds its shape, and has just the right blend of sweetness, spice, and chocolate.

These cookies aren’t just adorable—they’re also practical. You can bake them ahead, freeze them, or get the kids involved in decorating the little jack-o’-lantern faces. Comfort food, family fun, and chocolatey goodness all in one.

Why You’ll Love These Cookies

• Festive & Whimsical: Pumpkin shapes with jack-o’-lantern cutouts make them a perfect centerpiece for fall parties.
• Comfort with a Healthy Twist: Using warm spices like cinnamon, ginger, and nutmeg adds flavor depth, meaning you can keep the sugar moderate without sacrificing taste.
• Kid-Friendly & Crowd-Pleasing: They’re simple enough for little helpers but impressive enough to wow a crowd.
• Make-Ahead Friendly: You can prepare the dough in advance, freeze it, or assemble cookies just before serving.

Recipe Details

• Servings: 30 cookies
• Prep Time: 30 minutes
• Cook Time: 15 minutes
• Total Time: 45 minutes

Ingredients

For the Cookies

• 3 sticks salted butter, softened – The salt here balances the sweetness and spices. If you only have unsalted, add an extra ½ teaspoon salt.
• 1 ¼ cups light brown sugar, packed – Brown sugar keeps the cookies moist and adds a subtle caramel flavor.
• 1 tbsp pure vanilla extract – Rounds out the sweetness and brings warmth.
• 2 eggs, at room temperature – Eggs help bind the dough and add richness. Room temperature ensures they incorporate smoothly.
• 4 ½ cups all-purpose flour – Spoon and level to avoid packing too much flour, which can make the cookies crumbly.
• 1 tsp baking soda – Gives just enough lift while keeping cookies sturdy for sandwiching.
• 1 tsp cinnamon, ½ tsp ginger, ¼ tsp nutmeg – Classic warming spices for a cozy fall flavor.
• ½ tsp salt – Enhances all the flavors.
• 12 oz milk chocolate, melted – Creamy filling that balances the spiced cookie. Semi-sweet also works if you prefer less sweetness.

For the Cinnamon Sugar Coating

• 2 tbsp salted butter – Browned for a nutty, rich flavor.
• 3 tbsp cinnamon sugar – Adds sparkle and a final layer of spice.

Instructions (with Tips)

Step 1: Make the Dough

In a large mixing bowl, cream together butter, brown sugar, and vanilla until light and fluffy (about 3–5 minutes). This step is key—proper creaming creates air pockets, giving the cookies a tender texture.

Add the eggs one at a time, beating until fully incorporated. Scrape down the bowl to avoid streaks of egg or butter.

Stir in flour, baking soda, spices, and salt. Mix until just combined; overmixing develops gluten, which can make the cookies tough. The dough should come together into a ball but not be sticky.

Step 2: Shape the Cookies

Lightly flour your work surface. Divide the dough in half, flatten into disks, and roll out each piece to ¼-inch thickness. This thickness ensures cookies are sturdy enough for filling but still tender.

Cut out pumpkin shapes with a 3-inch pumpkin cutter. Place cookies on a parchment-lined baking sheet. For half the cookies, cut out jack-o’-lantern faces using a paring knife or small cutters. Keep designs simple—basic triangles and crescent smiles work best.

Chill shaped cookies in the freezer for 15–20 minutes. This step prevents spreading in the oven and keeps the edges sharp.

Step 3: Bake

Preheat oven to 350°F (175°C). Bake cookies for 8–12 minutes, until the edges are lightly golden but the centers still look slightly soft. Overbaking is the quickest way to dry them out, so check early.

Cool on the baking sheet for 5 minutes before transferring to a wire rack.

Step 4: Decorate the Tops

In a small saucepan, melt butter over medium heat until lightly browned and nutty (2–3 minutes). Let cool slightly. Brush over the jack-o’-lantern cookies, then sprinkle with cinnamon sugar. This adds both sparkle and flavor.

Step 5: Assemble

Spread melted milk chocolate over the flat side of the plain pumpkin cookies. Gently press a decorated jack-o’-lantern cookie on top to create a sandwich. Allow chocolate to set slightly before serving.

Storage & Make-Ahead Tips

• Room Temperature: Store in an airtight container for up to 3 days. Layer cookies with parchment paper to prevent sticking.
• Freezing the Dough: Shape cookies, freeze on a tray until firm, then transfer to a freezer bag for up to 2 months. Bake from frozen, adding 1–2 minutes to the bake time.
• Freezing Baked Cookies: You can freeze plain baked cookies for 1 month. Assemble with chocolate after thawing for best freshness.
• Refrigeration: Not necessary for baked cookies, but if your kitchen is warm, you can refrigerate assembled cookies to prevent chocolate from melting.

Recipe FAQs

❓ How long do the cookies keep?
Up to 3 days at room temperature, stored airtight. They’ll still taste fine after that, but the texture softens.

❓ Can you freeze the cookies or dough?
Yes! Dough freezes beautifully. You can also freeze baked cookies, but wait to sandwich with chocolate until after thawing.

❓ Do you have to refrigerate once baked?
No. Room temperature storage is best, unless your kitchen is very warm. Refrigerating can make cookies dry.

❓ What if I leave out the spices?
You’ll still get a delicious butter-and-vanilla cookie, but it won’t have that cozy fall flavor. You can substitute pumpkin pie spice or keep it plain for year-round baking.

❓ Why do my cookies turn out crumbly or powdery?
This usually means too much flour was added. Always spoon flour into your measuring cup and level it off, instead of scooping. Also, don’t overbake—the cookies should just barely turn golden.

❓ What size cutter should I use, and how do I make the face?
A 3-inch pumpkin cutter is ideal. For the faces, use a sharp paring knife to cut triangles or simple shapes. Avoid overly detailed designs—they’re cute but tend to break during baking.

Serving Ideas & Variations

• Make them spooky: Use dark chocolate instead of milk chocolate for a more dramatic contrast.
• Kid-friendly twist: Skip the spices and let kids decorate the faces with candy eyes or sprinkles.
• Thanksgiving version: Instead of jack-o’-lantern faces, leave cookies plain pumpkins and drizzle white chocolate over the tops.
• Healthier variation: Swap half the flour for whole wheat pastry flour and use dark chocolate for a fiber-rich upgrade.
• Mini sandwiches: Use a smaller cutter and serve bite-sized cookies for parties.

Sofie’s Notes

After baking seven batches, my biggest discoveries were:

1. Don’t skip chilling the dough. It’s the secret to cookies that hold their pumpkin shape.
2. Keep chocolate slightly melted but not runny when assembling—too hot and it will ooze out, too cold and it won’t spread smoothly.
3. Taste improves the next day as the spices settle and the chocolate softens the cookie slightly.

These cookies never last long in my house. They’re the first thing my family reaches for when the weather turns chilly. Whether you serve them at a Halloween party, tuck them into a lunchbox, or pair them with a steaming bowl of soup for dessert, they bring comfort and cheer.

Try these Milk Chocolate Stuffed Jack-O’-Lantern Cookies and make your fall gatherings unforgettable. For more cozy comfort-food recipes with playful twists, visit Home Cook Studio.

Print